For many longtime residents, the original Lag’s Eatery holds a special place in their hearts. Originally opened in the 1970s by “Lag” Gagliano, the beloved neighborhood cafe quickly became a gathering spot for locals. It wasn’t just about food—it was about community: a place to meet friends, see friends, and be friends, all while enjoying delicious meals and great conversation. After nearly four decades of service, Lag retired in the 1990s, passing the torch to Gerard DeFrank, who carried the legacy forward until his retirement in 2008 and Lag’s Eatery closed its doors.
But the story didn’t end there. Two former employees, Eric Wallace and Justin Shubert, were inspired by the place that shaped their lives. Both lifelong Birmingham residents worked at Lag’s when they were younger, and recently they decided to bring the iconic eatery back to life. In doing so, they were determined to honor the community and the memories that made Lag’s so special.
1 of 6
Photographs courtesy of Lag’s Eatery Facebook
2 of 6
Photographs courtesy of Lag’s Eatery Facebook
3 of 6
Photographs courtesy of Lag’s Eatery Facebook
4 of 6
Photographs courtesy of Lag’s Eatery Facebook
5 of 6
Photographs courtesy of Lag’s Eatery Facebook
6 of 6
Photographs courtesy of Lag’s Eatery Facebook
Eric and Justin are now the proud co-owners of Lag’s Eatery, located in the former Lolo’s Barbecue building on 3rd Court South in Crestwood. The duo gutted and renovated the entire interior, ensuring that it was not only a nod to the past but also a space that could meet their needs today. They also revamped the exterior, replacing the old gravel lot with a paved concrete surface and even building an additional structure for restrooms. The landscaping was completely transformed to create a welcoming, family-friendly environment.
For Eric and Justin, Lag’s Eatery is more than just a restaurant—it’s a celebration of community, history, and the bonds that form when people come together over a meal. Justin notes that he and Eric dreamed about reopening for years, and they’re excited to show people how much the place meant to them. They’re also deeply grateful for the community that supported them as they grew up here and want to rekindle the magic of those early days, where regulars were family and newcomers felt immediately welcome.
Lag’s Eatery is open for breakfast, lunch, and dinner—and yes, even late-night! It’s a place where families can gather for a casual meal—burgers, patty melts, chicken or bologna sandwiches, salads—and kids will be thrilled with the chicken nuggets, grilled cheese, or burger on their own menu. The thick, creamy milkshakes will satisfy everyone, and we highly recommend trying the Nutty Buddy or Girl Scout. (You can thank us, later!) Their breakfast sandwiches include a choice of bread (bun, biscuit, Texas toast), meat (bacon, Conecuh sausage, bologna, sausage patty), and egg or no egg; the pancakes are fluffy; and the breakfast plate is filling (try the tots!).
With its welcoming atmosphere, delicious food, and rich history, Lag’s Eatery has come full circle. The neighborhood cafe that once served as the first job for countless young people—including best buds Eric and Justin—is now ready to serve a new generation of guests. So, whether you're in the mood for a hearty breakfast, a satisfying lunch, or a late-night snack, head on over to Lag’s Eatery in Birmingham. The legacy is alive and well, and it’s waiting for you to be a part of it.
Lag’s Eatery is located at 4350 3rd Court South in Birmingham. Hours are 6-12 a.m. Wednesday, 6-2 a.m. Thursday-Saturday, and 10 a.m.-2 p.m. Sunday. For more information, visit lagseatery.com.